Design-added-value vs labour-added-value

-
Doy Santos aka The Cusp recently trumpetted in an article on ProPinoy.net how the Philippines "has emerged as a world leader in [the value of exports of high-tech manufactures], edging out Singapore, the former front-runner since 1996".

I pointed out in a comment on his article that...
Claiming we are "technology exporters" is like a stenographer making a claim to authoring a document that she merely typed out for his/her boss.

Specifically, much of what constitues the "value" of our exports of these goods can be deemed nothing more than labour-added-value. Our leg of the value chain of these exports involves factories that assembled materials that were pre-fabricated closer to their origins. Our workers implement production processes and follow assembly blueprints that were developed (read: designed) elsewhere.

In short, much of the design-added-value had already been input into the goods by the time they are landed as assembly kits on a Philippine port. The question, therefore, that Mr Santos needs to ask himself is this:

How much of the value of the export was added/created in the Philippines?

I elaborate further in another comment...
Say for example you export $100 worth of calculators, and $95 of that is accounted for by materials, handling, design, pre-assembly, and transport that happened before the kits for assembly arrived as an import at a Philippine port and hauled to the assembly plant in Cabuyao.

That means, the Philippine leg of the value chain contributed only $5 to the value of this export. The net added value of Pinoy enterprise is a small fraction of the total gross value of the export.

Looking to China for a bit of context, we find that awesome society moving in a different direction:
Now some of the most advanced research in this high-value, fast-growing field is being done in China -- instead of in the U.S. with American engineers.

While we cheer our role as an assembly outpost for electronic trinkets, China is positioning itself as a centre for design.

Pretty soon, we will be importing pre-fabricated kits designed in China as well.

Comments

  1. Ben Kritz8:21 pm, July 30, 2010

    Follow the link in his article of cherry-picked facts, and check out some of the other indicators. Of particular interest is the one that describes debt service as a percentage of exports. There's some other good ones, too, such as FDI, percent of paved roads, net migration, etc.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular this week

Filipinos cannot progress if they cannot follow even simple guidelines

-
Image
A noted blog commentator once made an assertion that the Philippines will never be a great nation unless Filipinos learn to live by the principle of the "rule of law". Indeed, some people even insist that none of the calls by certain sectors of Philippine society for a system change like a shift from a Presidential to a Parliamentary system or even constitutional amendments will work to uplift the status of the nation because Filipinos simply cannot follow the "rule of law."
Read more

Google Philippines' Top 20 most influential Filipino women

-
Image
I recently got a load of Google's list of most "influential" Filipinas (Filipino women) for 2010. The list is utterly dominated by performers along with a handful of notable exceptions: Senator Miriam Santiago (no. 10), Doris Dumlao (journalist, no. 12), Monique Lhullier (designer, no. 17), and Korina Sanchez (journalist, no. 19). These 20 ladies supposedly "grabbed the greatest online mindshare in 2010". So presumably, they reflect the substance of the Filipino collective mind.
Read more

Roundabouts to "solve" Manila traffic - a microcosm of flawed Filipino thinking

-
Image
Roundabouts (or "rotundas" as they are more commonly known as in the Philippines) are being touted by the cash-strapped Metro Manila Development Authority (MMDA) as "an alternative measure to ease traffic congestion". According to a "simulation study", the MMDA foresees a "200% increase in the speed" of areas where roundabouts can be successfully implemented. ABS-CBN News reports that MMDA spokesperson Tina Velasco expects the following specific benefits coming from the increased use of roundabouts in Metro Manila's intersections:
Read more